I think the distaste I was feeling towards the Porn Battle was based on a lack of fanfic that was
anything but porn. A writer who can manage to write a
story in so few words is impressive. I've always perceived a drabble, ideally, to be similar to a story, in that it is attempting to formulate a structure for itself - to follow an outline of dramatic rise and fall, though more loosely and with less detail than a fully fledged story would incorporate. But there are some drabbles that are, well,
invertebrate. They have no structure whatsoever. I don't think it was the smut that was getting to me. I love biscuits. I could consume a whole tray of them. But there is a difference between a smut biscuit and a smut...
glob.
That said, the Porn Battle seems to have been a lot better these last two days. The novelty of the first one's worn entirely off, but then I was very new to LJ when the first one happened, so it makes sense that it seemed novel to me then. There have been a couple of really great pieces, and, above that, the overall quality of the fics seems to have gone up. Fics like the angry and sexy
"Rumors" by
soft_thrills, and the sexy and gentle
"Balm in Gilead" by
aloysiavirgata are what a really great porn battle runs on. They're succinct but complicated, with implications that stretch far out beyond their humble word counts - true drabbles.
amalnahurryeh's fic
"Taxi Ride" is a very fine smut biscuit with an edge, and though it's something of a fully fledged stand alone fic, it is perfect in tone for a porn battle - sexy and fun and kind of
brazen, but not lacking in a slight sense of the underlying seriousness of the characters.
scooly42's drawing,
'Supply Closet' was both delightfully cheeky and well within the bounds of good taste -- thoroughly evocative of ten different fanfic scenarios, without being overly demonstrative. Then there's
bravenewcentury's fic
"The Even-Numbered Pages Are the Past". The conflict for me, here, is that calling such a fic 'porn' seems so utterly absurd that it takes my brain a moment to know what to do with the fic when read in the context of a porn battle. But no matter how incongruous a porn battle is as a backdrop, a fic like this one - even just a drabble - when spurred into words by a porn battle, will never fail to make the entire porn battle seem worthwhile in my mind.